Affordable Care Act, Hey Hey Hey Goodbye . . . What The House Cravenly Proposes To Demolish

Download PDF

Michael J. Matheron, May 5, 2017
[to download this post click the Adobe icon, above]

“The pursuit of peace and progress cannot end in a few years in either victory or defeat.
The pursuit of peace and progress, with its trials and its errors, its successes and its setbacks,
can never be relaxed and never abandoned.”

-Dag Hammarskjold, 29 July 1905 – 18 September 1961
Nobel Peace Prize 1961
[posthumous acceptance speech by Rolf Edberg*, Swedish Ambassador to Norway]
2nd Secretary-General of the United Nations
Died in airplane crash en route to negotiate a cease-fire between
“non-combatant” UN forces and Moise Tshombe‘s Katangese troops.

Hammarskjold’s final writing still holds true today. We’re losing long-fought battles we’d (foolishly, I suppose) believed were in the rear view mirror. Voting suppression abounds; discrimination rises again; firearms appear to be now the only truly unassailable right we possess; women are again under a renewed and ever more spiteful and dangerous attack, physically and politically; and our Pr~sident would have to improve his ways to be considered eligible for parole in a Turkish prison.

And today, except for 20 of their most nearly sane members, House Republicans brewed up their half-baked, half-assed repeal of the best of the ACA only to craft a health bill more reminiscent of the German Nuremberg laws of 1933, the GOP finally achieved “greatness” in malice and infamy and human and economic frugality that might have caused Ayn Rand herself to scream, “Enough!”

Remember, just three and a half years ago  . . . on September 26, 2013, President Obama spoke about the Affordable Care Act to a group at Prince George’s County Community College in Largo, Maryland. Signed into law on March 23, 2010, the President was in an interesting mood, happily basking in a major legislative achievement, yet dismayed by continuous, often demonic, GOP resistance:

THE PRESIDENT:  ]They have made such a big political issue out of this, trying to scare everybody with lies about “death panels” and “killing granny” —  — right?  “Armageddon.”  So if it actually works, they’ll look pretty bad.  If it actually works, that will mean that everything they were saying really wasn’t true and they were just playing politics.

Just the other day, one Republican in Congress said we need to shut this thing down before the marketplaces open and people get to see that they’ll be getting coverage and getting these subsidies because — and I’m going to quote him here — he said, “It’s going to prove almost impossible to undo Obamacare.”  Right?  So in other words, we’ve got to shut this thing down before people find out that they like it. That’s a strange argument.  Don’t you think that’s a strange argument?

And the closer we get, the more desperate they get.  I mean, over the last few weeks the rhetoric has just been cranked up to a place I’ve never seen before.  One congressman said that Obamacare is “the most dangerous piece of legislation ever passed.” Ever.  In the history of America, this is the most dangerous piece of legislation.  Creating a marketplace so people can buy group insurance plans — the most dangerous ever.

You had a state representative somewhere say that it’s “as destructive to personal and individual liberty as the Fugitive Slave Act.” Think about that.  Affordable health care is worse than a law that let slave owners get their runaway slaves back. I mean, these are quotes.  I’m not making this stuff up.  And here’s one more that I’ve heard — I like this one — we have to — and I’m quoting here — “We have to repeal this failure before it literally kills women, kills children, kills senior citizens.”  Now, I have to say — that one was from six months ago — I just want to point out we still have women, we still have children, we still have senior citizens.

All this would be funny if it wasn’t so crazy.  .  . [for complete speech]|

The phrase, “[a]ll this would be funny if it wasn’t so crazy,” was true, of course, the crazy. Yet, Sean Combs is right “It’s okay to be crazy, but don’t be insane.” The GOP, nearly en masse voted today to repeal the Affordable Care Act. an should the Senate, in some contagious mass hysteria, pass it with no meaningful changes, then the Republican party and Donald Trump have gone around the bend, beyond the moral pale, and with hearts of granite. They’re just being themselves. We’ve seen this coming since last November 8th.

“Something’s happenin’ here, what it is ain’t exactly clear’  Yet . . . .

Now’s the time to lower the joke-level (a challenge for me) and, if the House GOP’S Abominable Health Care Act (AHCA) passes the Senate, and Trump signs it,to instead begin to parade beyond marches, and prepare for mass protests, national strikes, and civil disobedience.

As de Tocqueville warned the uninterested and unbelieving French Chamber of Deputies in January 1848:

“We are sleeping on a volcano… A wind of revolution blows, the storm is on the horizon.”

Just a few weeks later revolution in France (and in Europe, generally) broke out. By November 4, 1848, the Second Republic of France is in place. Are we not sleeping on a volcano? Are our governments’ agents, unaware of the rumbling? When shall we awaken them?

The song below greeted the House GOP after they succeeded, by a hair’s breadth, to begin the demolishing of affordable, available, and economically viable health insurance for all Americans. The version  below from 2000’s Remember the Titans has, for those who may be shorn of all necessary and proper health care by the end of this year, has a funereal setting. Like today’s.

Secretary-General Hammarskjold’s completed writing the words at the outset of this post  on the flight that carried him and his group of peacemakers to their deaths. Peace seekers die in suspicious circumstances. Health care “peacemakers” figuratively die when their profound achievement, the ACA, crashes and burns with detritus and small intact pieces that somehow survive. I now believe that the GOP’s successful attack on health care is a true casus belli, a true cause for war, especially because thousands and thousands of vulnerable people will, indeed, die thanks to the GOP and their regular supporters and constituents (who, as is well-known, will suffer the loss of their hated “Obamacare”). We must restore the ACA, and extend its coverage to all Americans. Medicare For All. In the end, we will have to take (perhaps literally) most of the needed financing to do so primarily from the wealthy upper 10%; they’ll still have their 5o-foot long water toys and houses that have 16 toilets. In truth, they won’t feel it an iota. But, be ready, they will complain that they do. We’ll need to begin their re-education program asap . . .


Below are very helpful resources that will address a panoply of questions.


The Henry J. Kaiser Family Foundation

Kaiser Family Foundation’s Kaiser Health News is an excellent resource to follow many subject areas, provides an exceptional resource summing up what the GOP has wrought.

You many also be interested in…

The Upton Amendment to the ACA Repeal Bill Will Have Almost No Effect

A deal with moderate House Republicans would provide subsidies for just 76,000 more people with pre-existing conditions.



The Trump Uncertainty Rate Hike

Uncertainty created by the President and Congress could raise 2018 premiums by hundreds of dollars.


Save pagePDF pageEmail pagePrint page
Please follow and like us:
Download PDF

Michael Matheron

From Presidents Ronald Reagan through George W. Bush, I was a senior legislative research and policy staff of the nonpartisan Library of Congress Congressional Research Service (CRS). I'm partisan here, an "aggressive progressive." I'm a contributor to The Fold and Nation of Change. Welcome to They Will Say ANYTHING! Come back often! . . . . . Michael Matheron, contact me at

You may also like...


Get the latest posts delivered to your mailbox: